Monday, May 24, 2010

Australia/Israel ties will remain strong despite hysterical Australian-government overreaction

From an AIJAC press release, May 24, 2010

The Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council said that the Australia/Israel friendship is deep and broad and will continue to grow despite the Australian government's regrettable decision announced today that an Israeli diplomat be withdrawn.

Dr Colin Rubenstein, AIJAC's Executive Director, said, "While we understand and sympathise with the responsibility of the government to protect the integrity of the Australia passport system, in our view, this response was unhelpful. Australia has already made clear its displeasure over the abuse of Australian passports in the strongest of possible terms [in fact, already too strong - SL], which we believe was adequate to fulfil the government's responsibilities."

Dr. Rubenstein continued, "We would note in this regard that, while Australia followed a British precedent in its over-reaction, no similar step has been taken by Ireland, France or Germany, all of whom also allegedly had forged passports implicated in the killing of senior Hamas terrorist Mahmoud al-Mabhouh."

AIJAC National Chairman Mark Leibler added, "The claims of the Dubai authorities with respect to this case should not be accepted as necessarily unbiased and neutral, given Dubai's apparent past tolerance of Mabhouh's open and dubious activity on behalf of Hamas on Dubai soil. Therefore, irrespective of who was responsible, describing the killing of Mabhouh as 'murder' is questionable and ignores the likelihood that the killing of an active terrorist leader from a violent rejectionist organisation positively saved lives."

"As Foreign Minister Stephen Smith noted, Australia and Israel have a longstanding friendship and common interests, with the threats of a nuclear-armed Iran and anti-Western terrorism just two of the pressing world concerns which both countries will continue to confront together, despite today's decision," Mr Leibler concluded.

I would ask:
  • if Australia could have prevented the Bali bombing by forging some passports and killing a terrorist, would it have done so?
  • what protest has the Australian government made to the Dubai and other governments openly allowing terrorist activity? ...and if that protest is weaker than this action against Israel, why? (Is that the "act of a friend"?)

1 comment:

Steve Lieblich said...

The Federal Member for Melbourne Ports, Michael Danby, today responded to Foreign Minister Steven Smith's announcement that Australia will expel an Israeli diplomat as a result of the Dubai affair:

"I have previously & publicly (on Jon Faine's 774 program) said that I condemn the misuse of Australian passports by any other country. However, I do not agree with the government's decision to remove an Israeli diplomat from Canberra. Neither France, Germany or Ireland have asked for an Israeli diplomat to be withdrawn as a result of the Dubai affair.

This announcement comes at a time when Australia is supporting just resumed Middle East peace negotiations.

Australia has always been a good friend of Israel and I have no doubt that this relationship will remain, Mr Danby said.