Friday, September 08, 2006

Arab Assessments of the War in Lebanon

from MEMRI, Special Dispatch Series - No. 1277, September 1, 2006 ...

Following U.N. Resolution 1701 and the ceasefire in Lebanon, the Arab media published differing assessments regarding the outcomes of the war. Many writers declared that Hizbullah had won, and that its resistance is a source of pride for the Arab and Muslim nations. Others stated that both Hizbullah and Lebanon had received a crushing blow in this war, which had been conducted indirectly by Syria and Iran, and denounced the lack of self-criticism in the Arab world.

Follow this link to the MEMRI article which provides excerpts from the Arab press under the following headings:

Hizbullah Won the War
*If All the Neighboring Countries Fired Rockets on Israel Simultaneously, It Would Cease to Exist ...

Hizbullah and Lebanon Lost the War
*Everybody Lost the War ...
*Nasrallah Himself Admitted That the Kidnapping was a Mistake ...
*"The Destruction of Lebanon Can Never Be Described as a Victory for Hizbullah" ...
*"Israel Can Only Be Defeated Through Science and Knowledge" ...

Criticism of Those Claiming a Hizbullah Victory
*"The Arab Intellectuals Have a Serious Problem [in Defining] the Criteria for Victory and Defeat" ....
*"Israel Sees the War Realistically While the Arabs Continue to Market Illusions" ....
*The Lebanese are Refusing to Admit Defeat in Order to Avoid Responsibility ....
*"There is a Need to Form an Arab Investigation Committee" ....

Accusations Against Syria and Iran
*Syria's and Iran's Declarations of Victory Prove Their Involvement in the War ....
*Hizbullah Must Sever Its Ties With Syria and Iran for Lebanon's Sake ...
*"The U.N. Resolution Does Not Prevent the Resistance From Continuing" ....

No comments: